17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas

Miniature bride and groom cake topper on a layered wedding cake with strawberries.

17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas

Do you want a wedding cake that’s unique and stands out from the rest? Check out these 17 non-traditional wedding cake ideas! These cakes are sure to impress your guests and show off your personality.

Whether you’re looking for something elegant or quirky, there’s sure to be a cake idea here that catches your eye. So get ready to celebrate your big day with a one-of-a-kind wedding cake!

Wedding cake with white floral decorations for non-traditional wedding celebrations.

Recommended Posts


Cake has been served as part of the wedding ceremony since ancient times.

Wedding cakes have changed over the years and for the modern bride, it seems the choices are endless.

Traditionally the cake was eaten by the guests to bestow fertility on the couple so it was very important that everyone had a piece. Hence, the bigger the wedding, the bigger the cake needed to be. The icing was white to indicate the bride’s virginity and purity. The cake was also a symbol of the bride’s wealth. The taller the cake, the more layers or tiers, the luckier the groom is.

But people these days neither know or care about these traditions. How about ditching the traditional wedding cake and going for some of these fresh wedding cake alternatives?

17 non-traditional wedding cake ideas for your wedding

If you’re looking for something different than the standard tiered wedding cake, here are 17 non-traditional wedding cake ideas to consider. From ice cream cakes to tower cakes, there’s sure to be something that will fit your style and taste. So without further ado, let’s take a look at some of these unique ideas!

1. Croquembouche

A tall, luxurious, stylish, and pretty wedding cake? Oui! Wedding cakes are a tradition that dates back centuries, and there are now countless different styles and flavours to choose from. If you’re looking for non-traditional wedding cake ideas, why not try a croquembouche?

Croquembouche is a French dessert made from small balls of dough, called croques, that are deep-fried and then coated in sugar. The balls are then stacked into a pyramid and held together with caramel or chocolate. Croquembouche is usually served at special occasions like weddings, and it’s sure to impress your guests! Plus, it’s delicious – who wouldn’t want to eat their wedding cake?

Profiterole wedding cake for non-traditional wedding celebrations.
via stylemepretty.com
Unique wedding cake ideas for non-traditional celebrations.
via mauisangelsweddings.com
Elegant modern wedding cake with a creative bubblegum-inspired design.
via stylemepretty.com

2. Macarons as Wedding Cakes

Macarons scream chic and elegant at any event or party. If you’re going for elegance on your wedding day then macarons are a really great choice.

If you’re on the hunt for non-traditional wedding cake ideas, you’ve definitely come to the right place. These days, more and more couples are opting for creative cakes that reflect their personalities and style. And one trend that’s been gaining popularity lately is the macaron wedding cake.

Sure, macarons might not be the first thing that comes to mind when you think of wedding cake, but trust us, they’re definitely worth considering. For starters, they come in a huge range of colours and flavours, so you can definitely find something that matches your theme. Plus, they’re super chic and elegant – perfect for a sophisticated affair. And if you’re worried about them being too delicate, don’t be. Macarons are actually quite sturdy, so they’ll hold up just fine during your event.

So if you’re looking for non-traditional wedding cake ideas, be sure to keep macarons in mind. They might just be the perfect option for your big day.

Wedding cake with pastel pink, green, and brown macarons topped with a white bow.
via go-reception.com
Wedding cake with macarons and crystal topper for non-traditional celebrations.
via weddingomania.com

3. Cheesecake

What’s better than cake? CHEESECAKE! I’d totally ditch traditional wedding cakes for this one. When it comes to wedding cakes, there are no hard and fast rules. In recent years, couples have been opting for non-traditional cakes that better reflect their personalities and style.

For example, cheesecake is an increasingly popular choice for couples who are looking for something a little different. Not only is cheesecake delicious, but it also provides a wide range of options in terms of flavour and decoration.

Whether you’re looking for a classic New York-style cheesecake or something more unique, there’s sure to be a cheesecake that’s perfect for your wedding. So if you’re looking for something a little out of the ordinary, don’t be afraid to consider cheesecake as your wedding cake.

Elegant layered wedding cake decorated with fresh berries on a white marble board.
via pro.iconosquare.com
Wedding cake with strawberries for non-traditional wedding ideas.
via pinterest.com
Wedding cake with strawberries and "We do" toppers.
via savvydeetsbridal.com
17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via tastesofchicago.com

4. Cheese Cake!

How about a cake consisting of several wheels of cheese? This can look very fancy and can be served to your guests as one of the courses. Not traditional but a great talking point.

One non-traditional wedding cake idea that is becoming increasingly popular is cheese. Cheese cakes can be decorated in a variety of ways to suit the theme of your wedding, and they are sure to be a hit with guests. There are a few things to keep in mind when choosing cheese as your wedding cake.

First, make sure to select a variety of cheeses that will appeal to all taste buds. You may also want to consider pairing the cheese with fruit or nuts for added flavour and texture. Additionally, be sure to allow plenty of time for the cake to reach room temperature before serving; this will allow the flavours of the cheese to fully develop. With a little planning, a cheese cake can be a unique and memorable way to celebrate your special day.

17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via bloglovin.com
17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via bridemagazine.co.uk
17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via thetomkatstudio.com
17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via houseofcheese.co.uk

5. Sushi

If you love Sushi then it’s only apt to get yourself a gorgeous sushi layer that will replace the traditional wedding cake. Maybe it’s not for everyone but certainly something different! Accompanied with other desserts, this will keep everyone happy.

If you’re looking for a non-traditional wedding cake idea, why not try sushi? Sushi is not only delicious, but it’s also a unique and elegant way to serve your guests. You can have a variety of sushi rolls made to order, or you can even create your own custom roll.

Plus, there’s no need to worry about cutting the cake – simply let your guests help themselves! If you’re worried about the cost, don’t be – sushi is actually very affordable, especially when compared to traditional wedding cakes. So if you’re looking for a unique and budget-friendly wedding cake idea, consider sushi!

17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via weddingbells.ca
17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via tumblr.com

6. Pizza

I haven’t met anyone who said no to pizza. A pizza stack is a great idea for a couple who live for pizza! This can be served quite late in the evening just before the guests are to leave. After drinking and dancing all night, your guests will be very content to go home with a full tummy.

Unique pizza-themed wedding cake with a bride and groom cutting it.
via weddingplanningtips.info
Unique pizza wedding cake with layered pizza slices for a non-traditional celebration.
via lovellywedding.com
Wedding pizza cake with bride and groom topper, non-traditional wedding cake idea.
via doulacindy.com

7. Crepes, Waffles and Pancakes

Now this is a cake that says “LOVE”. It is a real statement piece and will photograph very well.  A crepe, pancake or waffle stack is a great option for the couple looking to do something different. Together the bride and groom can pour maple syrup over the stack while the crowd ooohs and arrrhs!

17 Non-Traditional Wedding Cake Ideas | Stay At Home Mum
via frostedpetticoatblog.com
Elegant non-traditional wedding cake with pink roses and rustic layers.
via capitolromance.com
Creative wedding cake alternatives for modern celebrations.
via southernweddings.com
Lavender-themed non-traditional wedding cake with fresh flowers and rustic design. Perfect for moder.
via frenchweddingstyle.com
Delicious non-traditional wedding cake decorated with fresh strawberries and red currants.
via bathcakecompany.co.uk

8. Donuts

Donuts taste great and the stacks look gorgeous. It also costs less than tiers of cake. It will definitely cut some of your wedding costs. A wedding is a special day to celebrate the love between two people. It’s a day when couples are surrounded by their closest family and friends, and they want everything to be perfect.

For some couples, that means having a non-traditional wedding cake. Doughnuts are a popular choice for non-traditional wedding cakes because they’re delicious and easy to personalize. You can have them custom-made with the bride and groom’s initials, or you can choose from a variety of flavours and toppings.

And if you’re worried about cutting into a non-traditional cake, don’t be! The phrase “something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue” can apply to non-traditional wedding cakes, too. So go ahead and ditch the traditional wedding cake in favour of something more unique – like doughnuts!

Wedding donut tower with "Mr & Mrs" cake topper for non-traditional wedding celebrations.
via planyourperfectwedding.com
Elegant lavender macaron wedding cake with floral accents.
via pinterest.com
Non-traditional wedding cake made with cookies and berries for unique celebrations.
via myweddingguides.com
Wedding cake with donuts for non-traditional wedding celebrations.
via engagingeventscharleston.com

9. Pie

When it comes to wedding cakes, there are nearly endless possibilities. While some couples opt for a traditional tiered cake, others are looking for something a little more unique. One non-traditional option that has been gaining popularity in recent years is the pie. Pies come in a wide variety of flavours, making them a great option for couples who can’t decide on just one.

They can also be decorated to suit any wedding theme. In addition, pies are typically less expensive than traditional wedding cakes. For couples who are looking for a non-traditional dessert that won’t break the bank, pies are an ideal option. Such a charming treat to serve to your wedding guests. Wedding pies look gorgeous with any wedding theme!

Non-traditional wedding cake featuring fresh raspberries, yellow flowers, and playful toppers.
via theknot.com
Creative wedding cake alternatives for modern celebrations.
via buzzfeed.com
Non-traditional wedding cake ideas with stacked pies and tarts for a creative celebration.
via paperandlace.com
Wedding cake topper with bride and groom figurines for unique wedding celebrations.
via ruffledblog.com
Wedding cake with "Mr. & Mrs." topper for non-traditional wedding celebrations.
via brides.com

 

10. Naked Cake

This one is closest to the traditional wedding cake but costs totes cheaper. It’s totally gorgeous, too, when decorated with fruits and flowers.

Vibrant wedding cake decorated with fresh flowers, berries, and edible flowers for a modern celebrat.
via pinterest.com
Elegant non-traditional wedding cake with berry decorations and a "Mr & Mrs" topper for modern coupl.
via mywedding.com
Wedding cake with figurines, strawberries, and layered sponge for non-traditional celebrations.
via orangerieevents.com
Stay At Home Mum
via gemmawilliamsphotography.co.uk
Stay At Home Mum
via pinterest.com

11. Brownies

If you’re a couple that’s crazy for brownies then it’s only fitting to have stacks of brownies on your wedding day!

Creative wedding cake ideas featuring chocolate blocks and vibrant fresh berries and grapes.
via cakecentral.com
Chocolate wedding cake with roses and flowers for non-traditional wedding ideas.
via youandyourwedding.co.uk
Chocolate wedding cake with figurines and floral decorations.
via honeyandthemoonphotography.co.uk

12. Pavlova

Getting married on Australia Day? Then a pavlova wedding cake is a really great idea!

Unique wedding cake decorated with fresh berries and edible flowers for a modern celebration.
via hellomay.com.au
Stay At Home Mum
via tanyazouev.com

13. Cupcakes

Cupcakes are a really great option for weddings instead of the three-tiered traditional wedding cakes. It’s easier to serve and looks really cute!

Unique sunflower-themed wedding cake with multiple tiers and floral decorations.
via deerpearlflowers.com
Beautiful wedding cake with cupcakes and roses for non-traditional celebrations.
via flickr.com
Wedding cupcake tower with assorted cupcakes and a small top cake for celebration.
via stylisheve.com

14. Burger Cake

This one’s probably the most unique one out of all the choices here but if you want a burger stack on your wedding day then don’t let anyone stop you! It’s your wedding remember that.

Creative wedding cake alternative with stacked sandwiches.
via neatorama.com

15. Rice Krispies

Share your love for Rice Krispies to your wedding guests! These ideas for Wedding Rice Krispies look super dainty and breathtaking…

Creative wedding cake designs for modern couples.
via weddinghalldreams.com
Beautiful non-traditional wedding cake featuring roses and soft pastel flowers.
via modwedding.com
Wedding cake with berries and floral decorations for non-traditional celebrations.
via aislesociety.com
Non-traditional wedding cake featuring layered rice cereal treats and purple accents.
via hifiweddings.com

16. Cinnamon Rolls

These wedding cinnamon rolls are goals!

Non-traditional wedding cake with rustic design and greenery accents.
via rykes.com
Stay At Home Mum
via kathrynharry.wordpress.com

17. Lamingtons

A very Aussie cake for a true blue Aussie wedding! Have the caterer stack and decorate it. Lamingtons are a crowd favourite and it will definitely keep all of your “hard to please” guests happy.

Stay At Home Mum
via hellomay.com.au
Non-traditional wedding cake with fresh strawberries and floral accents.
via polkadotbride.com
Creative non-traditional wedding cake arrangement with cupcakes and floral accents.
via polkadotbride.com

Remember the cake is still a big part of a couple’s wedding day so make sure you go for what you want and not what tradition dictates so. Your wedding, your cake! So make sure it is what you want it to be.

Cake, Brownies, Cheese or Donuts? Anyone?

author avatar
MaryLouise Cartwright
I am hilarious, I am laughing at myself right now. I am the mother of three children, two of which I have successfully booted out of the nest. I do love being a SAHM and I have been showing off my skill set in my castle for over 20 years now.

Discover more from Stay at Home Mum

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email

Have your say!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent comments

Discover more from Stay at Home Mum

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading