20 Food and Drinks You Should Stop Buying at the Supermarket

Peanut butter spread on a slice of toasted bread, ready to enjoy.

In case you missed it, we made a list of cleaning products you should stop buying at the supermarket.

And we don’t plan on stopping there!

We at SAHM have put our heads together and made another list – now consisting of foods we stopped buying from the supermarket. Why? Because we can make it at home!

Okay don’t get me wrong. I looove getting groceries. The air in the supermarket (for some weird reason) makes me feel relaxed. It’s actually therapeutic…. until you have to pay.

It’s not only convenient that we know what goes into our family’s meals. Making these foods at home has helped us cut our family expenses. We can save the accumulated money for a little family trip or hubby and I can go on some fancy dates!

1. Orange Juice

Nothing beats freshly-squeezed orange juice!

Get the recipe here!

Refreshing orange juice with lemon wedge for healthy drinks.
via itspeachykeen.com

2. Pop Tarts

If you loved pop tarts when you were a kid (or still love it as an adult), make your own pop tarts at home. The one at the supermarket is delicious, but this recipe makes better tasting pop tarts and you get to make a lot!

Get the recipe here!

Delicious homemade iced biscuits with sprinkles on a white plate.
via savingdessert.com

3. Naan Bread

Making Naan bread at home instead of buying it at the grocery store is such a win for me. Making it costs waay less and the taste is much more to my preference. I love how easy it is to make, too!

Get the recipe here!Fresh homemade flatbreads with garlic and herbs on a wooden board.


4. Pancake Mix

Removing pancake mix from your grocery list will help heaps in cutting your grocery budget. Pancake mix can be expensive, especially the most delicious ones. If you opt to buy a cheaper one, you’ll need to add more ingredients to make it taste better. You’re spending more if you think about it, and requires extra work. Skip all that and make things easy – make pancakes from scratch!

Get the recipe here!

Piled pancakes with honey and syrup, perfect for breakfast or brunch.


5. Mayo

If you’ve only ever eaten store-bought mayonnaise, then we really encourage you to try this Homemade Basic Mayonnaise recipe. It’s super easy to make at home, and will leave you wondering why you ever opted for store-bought in the past. If you are concerned about eating raw egg, then we suggest you should stop eating mayonnaise. bahaha

Get the recipe here!Mayonnaise is a common supermarket buy that you should consider stopping.


6. Ketchup

It’s hard to say goodbye to ketchup. It was hard for me to decide to take it out from our to buy list. It’s not something you can’t live without, but there are just foods that seem bland without it. Am I right or am I right?

Get the recipe here!

Stay At Home Mum
via wholenewmom.com

7. Hummus

When I learned how to make my own hummus, it made me feel like a fool who spent a lot on those store-bought ones! The homemade stuff tastes absolutely delicious and it’s incredibly easy to make!

For hummus recipes, click here!Stay At Home Mum


8. Choco Hazelnut Spread

Bye, Nutella.

Get the recipe here!

Chocolate spread in a glass bowl with a spoon for homemade treats.
via splendidtable.org

9. Jam

Homemade jams are the best! It’s full of flavour and you know you’re eating good stuff. This also makes a great DIY gift!

Get the recipe here!Healthy homemade strawberry jam made from fresh berries.


10. Peanut Butter Spread

Adios, Jif!

Get the recipe here!

Three jars of homemade nut butters with bread and a knife on a marble surface.
via inspiredtaste.net

11. Pizza Dough

When you realise just how easy it is to make your own Pizza Dough, you’ll be kicking yourself for ever buying it ready made. You only need TWO Freaking Ingredients.

Get the recipe here!Person shaping pizza dough with toppings and ingredients on rustic wooden surface.


12. Pizza Sauce

Another no-brainer recipe. WHY DID WE HAVE TO BUY PIZZA????? This stuff is amazeballs.

Get the recipe here!

Pizza sauce in a jar for homemade pizza.
via thekitchn.com

13. Pasta

Now pasta is really really cheap to buy but it is also really cheap to make and the homemade version not only tastes delicious it’s really fun to make, as well!

Get the recipe here!Fresh cookie dough with baking ingredients on a wooden surface.


14. Condensed Milk

Make it at home because the ones at the supermarket come in sizes that are too small. That’s not enough condensed milk for us.

Get the recipe here!Creamy soup in a bowl with pouring cream, on a rustic wooden table.


15. Biscuits

This recipe is of terrific value, makes loads and has lots of room for variations: BUT the best thing of all  you can make different flavours and then FREEZE the dough so you always have fresh biscuits 10 minutes away.

Get the recipe here!Delicious homemade lemon cookies perfect for a quick treat or dessert. Easy to make and full of fres.


16. Granola Bars

Five ingredients and no bake. Can’t live without granola bars? Then I suggest to make your own (and make lots!).

Get the recipe here!

Delicious homemade oatmeal bars with nuts and honey on a wooden board.

via minimalistbaker.com


17. Yoghurt

I like yoghurt. It’s delicious and it’s my grab and go snack. But the price…urgh…the ones at the supermarket can be quite expensive. So I’ve decided to learn how to make it at home. With this recipe, you can add flavourings like stewed fruits or honey.

Get the recipe here!Stay At Home Mum


18. Ice Cream

I pretty much love ice cream wherever it’s from. But when we need to tighten up the budget and I extremely want to eat ice cream, I whip some up instead of buy! This Honeycomb ice cream recipe is the bomb!

Get the recipe here!Delicious homemade ice cream served with crispy cookie pieces on a white plate. Perfect treat for ho.


19. Marshmallows

Try out this recipe for classic marshmallows and you’ll never go back to eating store-bought marshmallows again.

Get the recipe here!

Fresh white cheese cubes on a wooden surface, ideal for recipes and snacks.

via epicurious.com


20. Bread

If there’s one thing our house couldn’t live without, it’s bread. The ones at the grocery store tastes great, but I worry sometimes…can I trust what’s in the bread we eat? Then recently, a friend of mine convinced me to get a bread machine. I’m glad I made that decision.

Click here for bread recipes for the bread machine!

20 Foods You Should Stop Buying at the Supermarket | Stay At Home Mum


That’s it ladies and gents! Time to make a new grocery list and be sure to check it twice!

Do I need to buy this? Or should I make it at home?

20 Food and Drinks You Should Stop Buying at the Supermarket

Watch out for Personal Care items you should stop buying at the supermarket!

author avatar
Clare Whitfield Chief Editor
Clare Whitfield is the Editor of Stay at Home Mum and a recognised voice in practical home management for Australian families. Based in the northern suburbs of Sydney, she balances editorial leadership with life as a stay at home mum to two school age children. Her background in home economics and more than a decade of experience in recipe development, family budgeting, and household systems inform her work.

Discover more from Stay at Home Mum

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email

Recent comments

Discover more from Stay at Home Mum

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading