# Tribunal Decides On Baby’s Surname After Her Parents Fight Over Whose Surname She Should Take

- Link: https://stayathomemum.com.au/news-opinion/tribunal-decides-on-babys-surname-after-her-parents-fight-over-whose-surname-she-should-take/
- Published: 2017-12-01T15:07:04+11:00
- Author: Clare Whitfield

## _The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal has stepped in to decide a baby girl’s surname after her parents couldn’t agree over whose surname she should take._

The baby’s parents, who are separated, have agreed on her first and middle names,
but each of them wanted her to have their surname.

In a decision in May, the Victorian Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages decided
to give the baby her surname which is a hyphenated version comprising both of her
parents’ surnames.

However, the parents, who cannot be named for legal reasons, argued and challenged
the decision in the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The mother revealed that her relationship with the baby’s father was long distance
and that it did not last long, ending early in her pregnancy. She told the tribunal
that the father didn’t give much importance to his relationship with his daughter,
had not financially supported her and only visited her thrice since she was born
last January.

She said that the father only wanted her daughter to carry his surname as a sense
of pride in passing on his family name.

She also added that it would be emotionally difficult and confusing for her daughter
to carry her father’s name, which would lead to her being teased later on.

[⌊Baby resting on mothers shoulder highlighting family and legal decisions about surnames⌉⌊Baby resting on mothers shoulder highlighting family and legal decisions about surnames⌉ ](https://i0.wp.com/stayathomemum.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/name2.jpg?quality=89&ssl=1)

However, the father explained that his daughter should carry his name, because it
connected her to him, his family and her heritage. He told the tribunal that he 
would love to see his daughter more often, but was limited due to his interstate
responsibilities.

Giving his ruling in the case, VCAT senior member Ian Proctor decided that it was
in the girl’s best interest to take her mother’s name, given that the baby is living
with the mother and only had few visits from the father. “This will likely reduce
potential confusion for the child as to identity, particularly if the father proves
to be an absent parent,” he said.

In his ruling earlier this month, Mr Proctor also did not include the father’s surname
as the baby’s third given name since the baby will have a name of a person “who 
is a stranger to her”. “There unfortunately seems a real possibility that once the
issue of the child’s name is settled, he will have very little contact,” he said.“
Therefore, the correct and preferable decision is not to include the father’s surname
as part of the child’s name.”

Mr Proctor said that the child may change her name as a young adult. “Assuming the
parents agreed with such a wish, the child’s name as registered on her birth certificate
could be changed at that point in time, or by the daughter’s choice by deed poll,”
he said.

Source: [Essentialbaby.com.au](http://www.essentialbaby.com.au/pregnancy/baby-names/fathers-surname-scrubbed-as-vcat-steps-in-on-baby-girl-name-dispute-20171129-gzvb2y)

![author avatar](https://i0.wp.com/stayathomemum.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/
12/clare_whitfield_profile.webp?quality=80&ssl=1)

 Clare Whitfield Chief Editor

 Clare Whitfield is the Editor of Stay at Home Mum and a recognised voice in practical
home management for Australian families. Based in the northern suburbs of Sydney,
she balances editorial leadership with life as a stay at home mum to two school 
age children. Her background in home economics and more than a decade of experience
in recipe development, family budgeting, and household systems inform her work.

 [See Full Bio](https://stayathomemum.com.au/author/clare_whitfield/) [  ](https://stayathomemum.com.au/author/clare_whitfield/)