# Mum Sues Hospital After Mix-up Saw Her Baby Being Breastfed By Another Mum

- Link: https://stayathomemum.com.au/family/baby/mum-sues-hospital-after-mix-up-saw-her-baby-being-breastfed-by-another-mum/
- Published: 2016-12-12T10:00:07+11:00
- Author: Clare Whitfield

## _A mother is filing a lawsuit against a hospital in the US for negligence after her newborn son was breastfed by another woman in a terrible mix-up._

Mum Tammy Van Dyke gave birth to her son, Cody, in 2012, at Abbott Northwestern 
Hospital in Minnesota in the US.

Two days after giving birth, the staff accidentally placed Cody with another mum,
who had given birth to twins, then breastfeed Cody, thinking he was her baby, Liam.

Because of the mix-up, Cody had to go through blood tests for HIV and hepatitis 
for a year, all of which, thankfully turned negative results.

However, Ms Van Dyke has described Cody’s tests, which happened every three months,
as “horrible”, despite receiving a letter of apology from Abbott Northwestern hospital,
which acknowledged her son was placed in the wrong bassinet.

[⌊Mum sues hospital after mix up saw her baby being breastfed by another mum | stay
at home mum⌉⌊Mum sues hospital after mix up saw her baby being breastfed by another
mum | stay at home mum⌉[

After the 2012 incident, Ms Van Dyke told _KSTP-TV _her shock at the error. “In 
good faith you drop your child off at the hospital nursery with the nurses. Never
in a million years would you think this could happen or would happen,” she said.

Meanwhile, she said that the other mother who breastfed Cody was also highly distressed.“
It gave me peace of mind to talk to her. She was just as distraught as me that this
happened to her, and in the meantime, also didn’t know where her baby was,” Ms Van
Dyke said.

In 2012, Allina Health System, operator of the hospital, has released a statement
stating that standard procedures, which require staff to match codes on the baby
and mother’s identification bands, were not followed in this particular case.

However, on Monday, Michelle Smith, clinical program director at Allina Health said
that a new electronic procedure has since been implemented. “When the Mother Baby
Center opened in February 2013, we began using electronic identification bands for
the mother and infant that must be matched when returning the infant to the mother.
This helps us to assure the identity of the infant and mother are matched each time,”
she said.

Ms Van Dyke is determined to sue the hospital claiming they “negligently failed 
to care” for her son, saying that as a result, both parties have had to endure “
unnecessary medical treatment and tests”.

She is now seeking $50,000 in damages.

Meanwhile, a statement issued by NSW Minister for Health in January 2016 confirmed
that while the occurrence is rare, there had been a total of seven similar mix-ups
over the past four years in NSW hospitals.

Source: [Essentialbaby.com.au](http://www.essentialbaby.com.au/baby/breastfeeding/mum-sues-hospital-after-another-woman-breastfed-her-baby-20161209-gt7gtp)

![author avatar](https://i0.wp.com/stayathomemum.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2025/
12/clare_whitfield_profile.webp?quality=80&ssl=1)

 Clare Whitfield Chief Editor

 Clare Whitfield is the Editor of Stay at Home Mum and a recognised voice in practical
home management for Australian families. Based in the northern suburbs of Sydney,
she balances editorial leadership with life as a stay at home mum to two school 
age children. Her background in home economics and more than a decade of experience
in recipe development, family budgeting, and household systems inform her work.

 [See Full Bio](https://stayathomemum.com.au/author/clare_whitfield/) [  ](https://stayathomemum.com.au/author/clare_whitfield/)
